The High Value of an Indian PennyThe value of an Indian Penny ranges from 75 cents to $1.50 for common dates in worn condition.
First, if your coin was minted in the early years 1859 through 1878 most are worth $7 to $12 or more.
Second, Indian pennies have a few dates that are very valuable. For example, every Indian Head Penny collector needs an 1877 to complete their set and the price begins at $660.
Third, the condition of your coin is very important in determining value. Indian Pennies should be examined closely and a "Grade" assigned. Necessary to discover an accurate value. See below for more help on grading your coins.
The Uncirculated Indian Penny pictured is an example of a coin, because of its condition, is worth well over $25.